Is Something Wrong? is the twenty-second scary story from Scary Stories 3: More Tales to Chill your Bones. The story is meant to be comedic. Inspired by an African American ghost story in "The Ghosts of New York" by Louis C Jones.
The first title card depicts the creature hovering above the driver while tapping him on his back as he flees. The second title card depicts the driver feeling horrified while he is tapped on his back by the creature's skeletal hand.
Plot
A man's car broke down late at night way out in the country, after remembering passing an empty house minutes before the car broke down, the Driver of the car decided to stay the night there in order to get sleep, While in the house, he found wood in the corner of the living room and made a fire in the fireplace. Thereafter, he covered himself with his coat and slept.
The fire went out, freezing the room and awakening the driver. The man decided to get help when it nearly became morning. Failing to fall back to sleep as a large crash occurred, something large fell out of the chimney and laid on the floor for about a minute before it stood up and stared down at him. The man looked at the creature once and was horrified by it's appearance, provoking him to immediately start running until he paused long enough to be able to jump out of a window.
After jumping through the window, the driver continued running until he stopped due to his lungs hurting. As the driver stood in the road panting and trying to catch his breath, he felt something tap him on the shoulder. Turning around, he was confronted by the creature, who asked him "Is Something Wrong?"
Trivia
- The concept of a monster coming down a chimney was previously used in Me Tie Dough-ty Walker and What Do You Come For?.